How to Recover Faster After a Bad Game: An Athlete's Comeback Guide
- Dr Paul McCarthy
- Sep 29
- 14 min read
Brett Maher of the Dallas Cowboys made NFL history in a 2023 NFC wildcard game by missing four extra-point attempts - the first player to do so. This shows how even elite athletes can have remarkably bad days.
Every athlete faces games where nothing works out. Aryna Sabalenka double-faulted 18 times at the 2021 National Bank Open , while Boston Celtic Jayson Tatum missed 23 shots against the New York Knicks . Athletic recovery plays a vital role after such performances. Coaches have seen proper recovery make the difference between a temporary setback and a prolonged slump.
High-performing athletes need recovery more than ever to reduce fatigue and improve their performance . This athlete recovery guide will help you bounce back faster and stronger after disappointing performances. You'll learn about effective sports recovery methods and mental strategies that can revolutionize your response to setbacks.
Remember, your response to setbacks defines you more than the bad game itself.
Step 1: Acknowledge the Bad Game
Most athletes face a psychological rather than physical challenge after a disappointing performance. The game's end brings a flood of emotional responses. Research shows injured athletes' scores on the Impact of Event Scale match those of natural disaster survivors [1]. Bad games can create psychological patterns that resemble trauma responses.
Step 1: Acknowledge the Bad Game
Your mind might try to deny what the scoreboard clearly shows. Athletes often experience shock followed by denial right after a poor performance. This defense mechanism shields you from failure's emotional pain temporarily—but at what cost?
Why denial delays recovery
Hiding in denial might feel comfortable, but studies show it substantially delays recovery. Athletes who don't acknowledge poor performances make their recovery take longer. Sports psychology research proves that rushing through recovery stages—especially when you skip acknowledgment—only pushes the emotional processing further down the road [2].
Staying in denial creates these problems:
Negative emotions surface later when support isn't available
Lower rehabilitation and return-to-sport rates due to preinjury stress [1]
Difficulty in spotting and fixing actual performance issues
Future performance anxiety
Your mental state doesn't just affect psychological recovery—it shapes physical healing too. Research shows patients with preoperative psychological distress had higher pain scores and worse range of motion three months after rotator cuff repair compared to control groups [1]. This proves your mental approach directly influences physical recovery speed.
How to accept mistakes without judgment
Accepting poor performance doesn't mean you're okay with it. You need to acknowledge what happened without harsh self-judgment that hurts your recovery. Athletes often criticize themselves harshly after a performance [3], but this creates a cycle that holds them back from reaching their full potential.
Here's how to accept mistakes without judgment:
Normalize your emotions - Every athlete feels intense emotions after a bad game. You can feel disappointed without questioning your worth.
Separate facts from feelings - Look at what actually happened versus how you interpret it. This difference helps stop failure from seeming bigger than it is.
Focus on the present - Research shows self-critical thoughts pull you into past or future thinking, making it hard to stay present [3]. Keep your focus on the now.
Set a time limit - Take 24 hours or less to review the competition, then move forward [4]. This lets you reflect without getting stuck.
Self-compassion helps you stay present and accept mistakes as learning opportunities rather than defining moments [3]. Understanding that mistakes help you improve creates room for real growth.
Note that fixating on one mistake takes your head out of the game [3]. Sports recovery starts with acknowledgment—not endless self-criticism or pretending nothing happened. Mindfulness helps athletes develop a balanced mindset to process mistakes without letting them spiral out of control [5].
Step 2: Let Yourself Feel It
Emotions work like energy in motion — they must go somewhere. Athletes experience powerful feelings after a poor performance. These aren't just mental reactions; they're physiological responses that tell us how to act and adapt to what's happening around us [6].
Step 2: Let Yourself Feel It
Understanding emotional release
Sports bring out all kinds of emotions, from the adrenaline rush before a game to the gut punch of losing [7]. These feelings aren't random — they play specific roles in how we grow as athletes. Research shows that emotions can affect performance by a lot. They change our body's state and focus in ways that can help or hurt an athlete's game [6].
Athletes often make a big mistake during recovery: they try to push down or ignore their feelings. In spite of that, emotional regulation isn't about pushing emotions away. It's about getting to know them, expressing them, and using them the right way [8]. Think over this — once you know which emotional state helps you perform best, you can use specific strategies to boost your athletic recovery [6].
The reset process isn't about ignoring feelings—it's about working through them [9]. Here's the right way to release emotions and recover faster:
Name your emotions - Spotting what you feel is where it starts. Research shows athletes who can name their feelings exactly have better control over them [6].
Note that emotions don't last - They float by like clouds or fish in the ocean. When things get tough, tell yourself this feeling will pass [9].
Keep distance from your emotions - You have emotions, but they don't define you. Say "I feel angry" instead of "I am angry" - it sounds less permanent [9].
Move it out physically - Try quick reset moves: breathe out longer than in, shake your body, or focus on something you can see to stay grounded [9].
Why bottling up frustration backfires
In stark comparison to what many think, pushing down emotions makes them stronger, not weaker. Expressive suppression happens when people hide their emotional expressions to fit social norms [8]. To cite an instance, an athlete might hold back tears after losing to look tough. This approach comes with real costs.
Studies show hiding emotions leads to several problems:
Higher physical stress - While hiding emotions might avoid social awkwardness, it puts more stress on your body [8].
Weaker immune system - Research connects emotional suppression to higher death rates over 12 years [10].
Mental health problems - Athletes who bottle up emotions say they feel extra pressure and internal stress [11].
Worse performance - Athletes who can't handle negative emotions often make rushed choices or lose focus – both kill performance [11].
Former professional footballer Lee Hendrie shares a powerful story: "I went through stages where I was coming to the end of my career, I was fighting for contracts, I was injured, I was going through divorce...All of those things built up to make me try and take my own life on numerous occasions" [11]. He added, "Being a proud man and not actually wanting to tell anyone about my problems was horrendous" [11].
Letting yourself feel emotions can turn frustration into something useful. Your original frustration pushes you to clear obstacles blocking your goals [2]. But if you don't handle it quickly and well, frustration can trigger what psychologists call the "negative emotional chain," turning into anger and then despair [2].
The negative emotional chain works this way: unhandled frustration becomes anger, which creates tension, messes up coordination, and clouds thinking. This pattern continues until anger turns to despair, and you give up completely [12]. Each step down this chain weakens your belief in reaching your goals [2].
Learning about this process helps you recover faster after a bad game. Feel that first wave of frustration instead of pushing it down. This stops the destructive chain and keeps your recovery on track.
Step 3: Reflect Without Blame
The way athletes look at their performance can speed up or slow down their recovery. A blame-free reflection is the point where you move from emotional processing to creating useful insights that help you improve.
Step 3: Reflect Without Blame
Athletes often play the "blame game" when things go wrong. They point fingers at coaches, teammates, officials, or themselves. This mindset creates the biggest problem: you feel you don't control your performance and success depends on things you can't influence [13].
You need a better way to reflect - one that looks at facts separately from emotions and focuses on growth instead of fault.
Separate facts from feelings
We blame others to protect ourselves and boost our ego [14]. This reaction comes naturally, but you need to tell the difference between what actually happened and how you feel about it.
Here's how you can reflect without blame:
Look objectively at performance - See what happened without emotional judgment. You can change your mindset with one word - stop looking for what went "wrong" and start seeing what you did "right" and where you can get better [15].
Recognize your attribution style - Pay attention to how you explain failures. Do you blame:
Permanent factors ("I'll always choke under pressure")
Pervasive issues ("I'm terrible at everything")
Personal failings ("It's all my fault") [1]
Find middle ground - Stay away from extreme self-blame or avoiding responsibility. You need balance between taking too much personal responsibility and not enough [16].
Athletes focus so much on winning that they forget what sports really mean: growth and development [17]. A shift from mistakes to opportunities puts you in a growth mindset that helps you recover faster [15].
Ask the right questions: what, not who
Your recovery speed depends on the questions you ask yourself after a poor performance. "Who messed up?" takes you nowhere, but "What happened?" and "What can I improve?" help you move forward.
These questions can help you reflect better:
"What did I do well today?" - Building confidence through your strengths relates directly to better performance. Find something good even on your toughest day [18].
"Where can I improve?" - This question works better than "What did I do wrong?" The small change keeps you focused on growth instead of fault [15].
"What specific actions will help me improve?" - An action plan turns your thoughts into practical steps [19].
Athletes who develop self-reflection skills control their energy better, feel more confident, and set better goals [20]. Those who keep blaming others take longer to recover because they don't take charge of their improvement [14].
These approaches give you different results. Blaming others protects your ego but stops you from learning. Saying "It wasn't my fault" might feel good now but tells your brain nothing needs to change [14]. Better reflection keeps you learning - exactly what you need to recover faster as an athlete.
Step 4: Rebuild Your Mental Game
Your mental game is the foundation of athletic performance. After you process emotions and reflect objectively, the next step to recover faster involves rebuilding mental strength through science-backed techniques.
Step 4: Rebuild Your Mental Game
Mental techniques work well to improve sports performance and help athletes bounce back from setbacks [21]. About 96% of athletes know at least one mental technique, but they don't always use them regularly [21]. This gap between what athletes know and what they actually do gives you a great chance to improve your recovery process.
Use visualization to reset confidence
Visualization (also called imagery) helps athletes become skilled at handling stressful situations [3]. This powerful technique lets you mentally rehearse a skill, routine, or performance to prepare your body for success [5].
Visualization works so well for sports recovery because of how it affects your brain. Your brain activates the same regions whether you're visualizing or physically performing an action [5]. This strengthens the neural pathways linked to physical execution without actual practice—training your brain for better outcomes [22].
Athletes coming back from poor performances can benefit from visualization in several ways:
Rebuilds self-confidence - Goal imagery improves performance because knowing how to vividly imagine successful outcomes boosts confidence during competition [3].
Provides emotional regulation - Adding emotions to imagery helps you develop self-regulation skills that support physical self-efficacy [3].
Continues training mentally - You can keep developing skills through visualization when you're physically or emotionally drained [23].
Reduces performance anxiety - Visualization helps athletes eliminate unknowns that create competitive anxiety [5].
You can use visualization effectively for athletic recovery by:
Practice self-talk and affirmations
Your internal dialog—self-talk—shapes your performance by strengthening focus, concentration, and self-belief [24]. Research shows positive self-talk creates happiness and excitement that leads to success, while negative thoughts increase anxiety [4].
Self-talk comes in different forms:
Athletes who use self-talk have more fun and interest while seeing higher effort value and competence [25]. Positive self-talk also improves performance-related motivation, boosts self-confidence, increases effort, controls attention, and manages anxiety [25].
Affirmations—positive, present-tense, empowering statements—work with self-talk by creating new connections in your brain's neuroplasticity [6]. These statements rewire your subconscious mind and turn negative thought patterns into productive ones [6].
Here's how to create effective affirmations for sports recovery:
Write realistic statements that match your values and goals [6].
Use first-person pronouns like "I" or your name (research shows using your name or "you" works better than "I" statements) [9].
Focus on what you should do instead of what you shouldn't do [9].
Practice daily, knowing it usually takes one to three months to see results and about six months for lasting changes [26].
Try these affirmations to help recovery:
Using these mental techniques regularly creates a foundation for faster recovery and renewed confidence. Visualization and positive self-talk together help you move quickly from disappointment to being ready for your next athletic challenge.
Step 5: Get Back to Training with Purpose
Getting back to physical training after a disappointing performance needs a smart game plan. Moving your body again isn't just about physical conditioning—it's about rebuilding confidence through activities that connect you back to your sport's fundamentals.
Step 5: Get Back to Training with Purpose
Set short-term goals for progress
Short-term goals work as stepping stones to reach your bigger athletic dreams. Research shows that goal setting works like climbing a mountain—you need smart short-term targets to reach the summit [28]. These small wins create momentum that pushes your recovery forward.
Here's what you need to do when setting goals after a setback:
Short-term goals really shine when it comes to preventing burnout, which sneaks up on you over time rather than hitting all at once [2]. So, checking off completed goals gives you real proof of improvement—this works both visually and mentally, showing your achievements while boosting your self-efficacy [12].
Use training to rebuild rhythm
Rhythm in athletics goes beyond timing—it helps you find your natural flow again. Without doubt, rhythmic training offers a promising way to improve timing performance and movement efficiency in athletes [30]. This training helps establish good proprioception and improves motor coordination ability [31].
Your path to rebuilding rhythm should include:
Rhythm training moves through clear phases—from adaptation to learning, intensive work, and finally sport-specific techniques [31]. The sort of thing I love about this process is how you learn to feel the rhythm naturally, not just understand it in your head [32].
Note that serious athletes should treat recovery with the same focus they bring to competition [33]. Unlike tough training sessions that push your limits and feel uncomfortable, good recovery should leave you feeling refreshed [33]. This balance between high-stress competition and gentler recovery creates the perfect environment for athlete recovery.
Smart short-term goals combined with rhythmic training create a clear path back to peak performance—building your confidence through small wins while bringing back your natural athletic flow.
Step 6: Turn the Page and Move Forward
Athletes need more than mental processing to bounce back from setbacks - they need a well-laid-out preparation plan to tackle future challenges. Athletes use preparatory routines as key patterns of physical and mental actions before they perform [11].
Create a pre-game reset routine
Pre-performance routines help athletes manage their psychological responses to stress and let their motor processes work naturally [11]. These routines usually include:
Mental visualization - Top athletes practice seeing different scenarios they might face and plan their responses [10]
Controlled breathing - Box breathing techniques help your mind drift away from anxious thoughts [34]
Positive self-talk - You can set yourself up to succeed by walking through the event with encouraging words [10]
Studies show that routines help athletes zero in on what matters while filtering out distractions [11]. Your routine should help you switch from daily life into a performance-ready state of mind [34].
How to stay focused on the next challenge
Success comes from "conscious amnesia" - you learn from mistakes and then let them go [35]. Here's how to keep your focus sharp:
The more time you spend dwelling on a bad game, the deeper it sticks in your mind [8]. Your ability to bounce back depends on your attitude and focus - mental skills that grow stronger with practice [8].
Conclusion to Recover Faster after Setbacks
Athletic recovery after a poor performance ranks among the most valuable skills you can develop as an athlete. This piece explores an all-encompassing approach to bounce back from setbacks, both mentally and physically.
Athletes who become skilled at these recovery techniques have a clear edge over others. You'll get back to peak form faster when you know how to accept poor performances, handle emotions well, think constructively, and rebuild your mental strength.
Bad games happen to everyone - even top professionals face devastating performances. Champions differ from average competitors not by avoiding failure but by how they respond afterward.
Recovery needs active work and practice. Each step builds on the last one and creates a path back to confidence and peak performance. The process might feel uncomfortable at first, but honest reflection and emotional awareness are the foundations of real improvement.
On top of that, visualization and positive self-talk help rebuild your mental game. These methods rewire your brain and create stronger neural pathways linked to success while helping you manage performance anxiety.
Focused training wraps up the recovery cycle. Short-term goals show clear progress while rhythm-based practice helps you find your natural athletic flow again. This mix rebuilds both physical skills and competitive spirit.
Of course, good pre-performance routines shield you from dragging past disappointments into new competitions. These routines reset your mind and let you face each challenge with fresh focus.
Moving forward, each recovery experience gives you a chance to build athletic resilience. Every time you guide yourself from disappointment to renewed confidence, your mental strength grows. So what once felt devastating becomes just a temporary setback - a stepping stone to bigger achievements.
Next time you face a disappointing performance, note that champions aren't defined by never failing but by how quickly they bounce back stronger.
Key Takeaways
Recovery from a bad athletic performance is a skill that separates champions from average competitors. Here are the essential strategies to bounce back faster and stronger:
• Acknowledge without denial - Accept poor performances immediately rather than avoiding reality, as denial only delays recovery and prolongs negative emotions.
• Feel emotions, don't suppress them - Allow yourself to process disappointment naturally; bottling up frustration leads to increased stress and impaired performance.
• Reflect on "what" not "who" - Focus on improvement opportunities rather than blame, asking constructive questions that promote growth instead of fault-finding.
• Rebuild confidence through visualization - Use mental imagery to strengthen neural pathways and program your brain for success while regulating emotions.
• Return to training with purpose - Set achievable short-term goals and use rhythmic training to rebuild your natural athletic flow and competitive confidence.
• Create pre-game reset routines - Develop structured mental and physical preparation patterns that help you turn the page and approach future challenges with fresh focus.
The key insight is that recovery is an active process requiring intention and practice. Each step builds upon the previous one, transforming what could be a prolonged slump into a stepping stone toward greater athletic achievement.
References
[1] - https://www.trainheroic.com/blog/performance-psychology-series-part-3-self-reflection/[2] - http://www.playerdevelopment.usta.com/About-USTA/Player-Development/sport_psychology_for_achieving_optimum_experience/[3] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12021890/[4] - https://members.believeperform.com/positive-self-talk-in-sport/[5] - https://www.peaksports.com/sports-psychology-blog/sports-visualization-athletes/[6] - https://championsquest.com/positive-affirmations-link-to-improved-sports-performance/[7] - https://mpowerminds.com/blog/emotion-in-sports[8] - https://www.peaksports.com/sports-psychology-blog/rebounding-after-a-bad-performance/[9] - https://www.coachestoolbox.net/mental-toughness/positive-self-talk-for-your-athletes[10] - https://www.asics.com/au/en-au/blog/6-winning-ways-athletes-mentally-prepare-for-competition/[11] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9374066/[12] - https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/the-whole-athlete/201501/the-effects-of-psychology-on-athletic-performance[13] - https://www.peaksports.com/sports-psychology-blog/why-athletes-engage-in-the-blame-game/[14] - https://www.scienceofrunning.com/2018/09/the-blame-game-how-our-reaction-to-failure-influences-future-performance.html[15] - https://www.successstartswithin.com/sports-psychology-articles/goal-setting-for-sports/how-to-evaluate-your-performance-for-future-success/[16] - https://medium.com/change-your-mind/stopping-the-self-blame-game-9b777a0c1b78[17] - https://skillshark.com/athlete-self-assessments-benefits/[18] - https://drstankovich.com/the-athletes-mindset-three-daily-questions-for-optimal-performance/[19] - https://www.sport.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/2024-09/Tips-to-hone-your-self-reflection.pdf[20] - https://playerdevelopmentproject.com/the-importance-of-self-reflection/[21] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4875065/[22] - https://www.performancepsychologycenter.com/post/visualization-techniques-and-mental-imagery[23] - https://www.successstartswithin.com/sports-psychology-articles/visualization-for-sports/visualization-techniques-for-athletes/[24] - https://optimihealth.ai/what-is-self-talk-and-how-can-it-help-me/[25] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7429435/[26] - https://nfhca.org/how-do-positive-affirmations-promote-athlete-mental-health/[27] - https://voiceinsport.com/post/mind/creating-and-practicing-affirmations[28] - https://appliedsportpsych.org/resources/resources-for-athletes/principles-of-effective-goal-setting/[29] - https://webber-nutrition.co.uk/goal-setting-in-sport/[30] - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1440244023004243[31] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10389069/[32] - https://breakingmuscle.com/rhythm-is-an-athlete-3-tools-for-learning-rhythm/[33] - https://simplifaster.com/articles/programming-recovery-planning-purpose/[34] - https://thementalgame.me/blog/performing-under-pressure-mental-strategies-elite-athletes-use-to-stay-calm-and-focused[35] - https://www.peaksports.com/sports-psychology-blog/how-to-move-on-after-a-bad-performance/[36] - https://bostonsportpsych.com/letting-go-mistakes-poor-performances/[37] - https://www.peaksports.com/sports-psychology-blog/6-steps-pregame-mental-preparation/
