How to Beat Sports Anxiety: A Pro Athlete's Step-by-Step Guide
- Dr Paul McCarthy
- 7 minutes ago
- 10 min read
Sports anxiety affects up to 70% of athletes at some point during their careers.
Performance anxiety in sports goes beyond just feeling nervous. The condition affects between 30% to 60% of all athletes, making it one of the most common mental challenges they face. Athletes experience physical symptoms like rapid heartbeat, sweating, and those familiar "butterflies" in the stomach, but the effects go much deeper. Sports performance anxiety can impair an athlete's focus, decision-making, and muscle coordination - significant elements needed to perform at peak levels.
Mental strength, not physical ability, often separates good athletes from great ones. Elite athletes aren't immune to these challenges. Four-time Olympic gold medalist Simone Biles withdrew from several events during the Tokyo Olympics because of mental health concerns, including performance anxiety.
In this piece, we'll help you identify sports anxiety symptoms and understand your anxiety triggers. You'll learn proven techniques that professional athletes use to overcome sports anxiety and deliver their best performance at the time it matters most.
Recognising Sports Anxiety in Real Time
You might find it hard to spot sports anxiety when you're competing, but knowing the signs helps you deal with it better. Sports performance anxiety shows up differently from regular nerves. It affects your body and mind in ways that can really hurt how well you play.
Common physical symptoms during competition
Your body sends clear signals when sports anxiety kicks in. These signs show up when your fight-or-flight response turns on, and they can mess with your movements and physical abilities.
Here's what you might notice in your body:
Your heart races and beats faster
You can't catch your breath or breathe too quickly
You sweat more than usual and shake
Your muscles get tight or you get headaches
Your stomach acts up and you need frequent bathroom breaks
Your chest feels tight and your mouth gets dry
These body changes do more than just make you uncomfortable—they get in the way of playing well. To name just one example, tight muscles can limit how well you move and coordinate. It also messes with your sleep, which you need to play your best [1].
Mental signs like overthinking and fear of failure
Sports anxiety hits your mind just as hard as your body. The mental symptoms can actually be worse. Athletes who deal with this often feel terrified of failing and can't focus [2]. You might catch yourself overthinking basic moves or drawing a blank on skills that usually come easy.
When you start doubting yourself, it creates a trap. The more worried you get about losing, the more you set yourself up to play poorly [2]. This turns into a loop—anxiety makes it harder to use your training and skills.
Your head might fill up with negative thoughts that play over and over. These thoughts make it impossible to do what you need to win [1]. Many athletes feel doom and gloom before or during games. They beat themselves up and expect too much [3].
How to tell if it's anxiety or just nerves
Every athlete gets butterflies before a game. But there's a big difference between feeling nervous and letting those nerves control how you play [4].
Getting nervous before competing is normal and can actually help you focus better and stay motivated [5]. But real sports anxiety changes how you act in the game. You might play it too safe—getting rid of the ball quickly, staying away from tough plays, or not taking shots because you're scared to mess up [4].
When anxiety takes over, it can make you "choke"—suddenly forget how to play under pressure [3]. The weird thing is, trying harder when you're very anxious only makes things worse [3].
Watch for signs like a tight jaw, moving too fast, making weird mistakes, or losing your cool (like when tennis players throw their rackets) [4].
Knowing these differences helps you spot when normal game-day jitters have turned into something that hurts your game. Then you can use the right tools to get back on track before your performance takes a hit.
What Triggers Performance Anxiety in Sports
Athletes often don't realize how deep the root causes of sports anxiety run. You need to understand what triggers performance anxiety to develop ways to cope with it. Internal pressures, external expectations, and situational factors combine to create overwhelming stress.
Perfectionism and high expectations
Perfectionism drives sports anxiety in athletes of all competitive levels. Athletes set unrealistic standards that consume them. A swimmer might obsess over a tiny 0.1-second difference in their time [6]. This endless chase for perfection traps them psychologically - anything less feels like complete failure.
Athletes with perfectionist tendencies think in extremes. They see themselves as either winners or complete failures [7]. This mindset creates intense anxiety during competition, especially when perfectionist athletes face the reality that mistakes will happen [8].
Research shows perfectionism evolves into what psychologists call "maladaptive perfectionism" - athletes can't handle it when they don't meet their impossible standards [4]. Unlike healthy ambition, this type of perfectionism can devastate athletes with burnout, anxiety, depression, and suicidal thoughts [4].
Fear of judgment and social pressure
Social anxiety hits hard, especially in sports with public performances. Research shows 85% of athletes feel pressure from external sources to succeed [6]. This constant evaluation creates what psychologists call "fear of negative evaluation" (FNE) - athletes worry others will judge them harshly [5].
Solo competitors feel more anxious than team sport athletes [7]. Young athletes show higher stress levels and fear of judgment compared to experienced ones [5].
Spectators play a huge role in anxiety levels [5]. Social media adds another layer of pressure - athletes face judgment not just from teammates but from millions worldwide [4].
Anxious athletes focus on avoiding mistakes instead of winning - a mindset that changes their entire performance [9]. They hesitate to make decisions, lose confidence, and struggle to stay focused while trying to please everyone [9].
Lack of preparation or experience
New athletes feel more anxious than pros because they haven't developed good coping skills [7]. Their limited competitive experience makes everything harder.
Kids and teens struggle more with sports anxiety than adults. A 2018 study of 59 research papers found that teenage athletes experience anxiety more intensely than adults [2].
Big competitions can overwhelm athletes who don't feel ready. Self-doubt creeps in when they question their practice or abilities [10]. This creates a nasty cycle - anxiety about being unprepared leads to poor performance, which makes the original anxiety worse [11].
These triggers are the foundations for managing and beating sports anxiety. You can develop targeted solutions once you identify what fuels your specific anxiety.
Step-by-Step Tools to Beat Sports Anxiety
Let's explore proven techniques to overcome sports anxiety now that we understand its causes. Top athletes use these strategies to deliver their best performance when it counts. These methods changed how I performed under pressure during my competitive athlete days.
1. Use pre-performance routines
A consistent pre-performance routine creates a sense of control and familiarity in high-pressure moments. Studies show that pre-performance routines improve performance in many sports, from basketball free throws to golf putting and tennis serving [12]. These routines combine physical actions with mental techniques to help you reach your peak state.
Your effective routine should:
Stay consistent and organized
Include sport-specific movements
Add breathing, visualization, and self-talk
Become automatic through practice
Make your routine brief but complete enough to focus your mind before competition.
2. Practice deep breathing and grounding
Your breathing becomes shallow when anxiety hits. Deep breathing triggers the vagus nerve to reduce your "fight or flight" response [13]. Box breathing works well to calm your nervous system - breathe in for 4 seconds, hold for 4 seconds, breathe out for 4 seconds, and hold again for 4 seconds [14].
The 5-4-3-2-1 technique helps you ground quickly:
Look at 5 things around you
Touch 4 different textures
Listen to 3 distinct sounds
Smell 2 different scents
Taste 1 thing [13]
This method keeps you present and stops anxiety from taking control.
3. Reframe anxiety as excitement
Studies show that turning anxiety into excitement works better than trying to calm down [15]. Anxiety and excitement share similar high-energy states, making this change easier than suppressing your feelings.
Just telling yourself "I am excited" before you perform can boost your results. One study found that people who reframed their anxiety scored 8% higher on math tests [16] and did better at public speaking and karaoke.
4. Visualize successful outcomes
Visualization works because it activates your brain's same regions as physical practice [17]. Athletes who use visualization techniques can cut their anxiety by up to 38% [18].
Make your visualization work by:
Using all senses (sight, sound, touch)
Seeing through your own eyes
Practicing often to build mental strength
Including real competition details
5. Use positive self-talk
Your self-talk shapes your performance by changing how you feel. Research shows that positive self-talk builds motivation, confidence, and enjoyment [19]. Athletes who use self-talk have more fun, value their effort more, and show greater skill.
Create personal affirmations that stay positive, present-tense, and realistic. Phrases like "I am a champion" or "I embrace challenges as opportunities" can change your mindset [20].
6. Focus on the process, not the outcome
Thinking about results creates anxiety because you can't control them. Process-focused thinking means concentrating on specific actions that lead to success [21].
This method helps you:
Lower anxiety and fear
Stay consistent
Recover from mistakes
Reduce perfectionism
7. Build a support system
Success in sports never comes alone. A strong support network of coaches, medical staff, family, and teammates promotes a safe mental environment [22]. Good relationships with your support team make it easier to ask for help with mental health concerns.
Pick trusted people who care about your wellbeing and respect your privacy when discussing mental health.
8. Practice under pressure
Building resilience comes from practicing under pressure. Pressure training adds stress during practice to help you handle competition pressure better [23]. While this training might not reduce anxiety, it teaches you to perform well despite feeling anxious.
Coaches create pressure through consequences, evaluation, or competition scenarios to help you develop reliable coping strategies for real competitions.
Training Your Mind Like a Pro Athlete
Mental strength sets elite athletes apart from average performers. After mastering technical skills, top athletes train their minds to excel under intense pressure.
Trusting your training and instincts
Elite athletes build deep trust in their abilities through consistent practice. Their movements become automatic and they resist the urge to overcontrol [24]. Athletes who trust their training make better decisions and don't second-guess themselves. They use better techniques and take calculated risks without overanalyzing [24].
Athletes with trust in their game step up during critical moments. Their self-confidence makes performance look effortless [24]. Real self-trust isn't blind faith - it's about believing in your decision-making process [25].
Letting go of overthinking
Overthinking guides you toward perfectionism and the dreaded "paralysis-by-analysis" syndrome [7]. Your focus should change from internal to external thoughts [7]. The train-it-trust-it process works best: develop your talent in practice, trust it in competition, and keep repeating [7].
Your brain handles trust differently than analytical thinking. A clear mind allows natural reactions [26].
Staying present during high-pressure moments
Peak performance happens in the present moment. Athletes perform best when they focus on their current actions [27]. Regular mental training creates clarity and calm that helps athletes perform in a flow state, often called being "in the zone" [28].
The W.I.N. strategy helps you stay present - ask "What's Important Now?" to reconnect with the moment [27].
Building Long-Term Mental Strength
Athletic excellence demands more than short-term techniques - it requires building lasting mental resilience. Long-term psychological strength forms the bedrock that supports all other performance skills.
Developing psychological flexibility
Psychological flexibility shows how well you adapt to changing circumstances while focusing on what truly matters [29]. Athletes with rigid thinking patterns struggle, but flexibility helps you handle adversity without feeling overwhelmed. Research shows this skill directly connects with reduced anxiety and depression symptoms in athletes [29].
Psychological flexibility consists of six interconnected processes: acceptance, present-moment awareness, cognitive defusion, self-as-context, values identification, and committed action [29]. These components teach you to respond effectively to challenges instead of reacting automatically. Athletes who score higher in psychological flexibility demonstrate better performance outcomes [30].
Accepting discomfort without reacting
Athletic pursuits inevitably bring pain and discomfort. Your relationship with these sensations determines their effect on performance. Research reveals that successful ultra-endurance athletes display greater psychological flexibility, which lets them accept pain without emotional distress [31].
This key difference matters—you can't achieve performance excellence while staying comfortable [4]. These two states cannot exist together. Athletes who accept discomfort as a natural part of their competitive path reduce their suffering and stay focused on performance goals.
Creating a balanced identity beyond sports
A multifaceted identity shields you from the psychological risks of being solely defined by athletics. Athletes who only identify with their sport often face serious distress during injuries, slumps, or career transitions [8].
Mental flexibility acts as a protective barrier that helps you look at challenges to your athletic identity more objectively [32]. Self-complexity—having multiple identity aspects beyond athletics—provides vital protection during setbacks [32].
True balance emerges when you actively nurture relationships and interests outside your sport. You become more than just an athlete—you're also a student, friend, family member, and community contributor.
Conclusion
Becoming skilled at managing sports anxiety is an ongoing experience, not a destination. In this piece, we've explored how identifying anxiety symptoms, understanding personal triggers, and using proven techniques can reshape your athletic performance. Anxiety affects most athletes at some point, but your response to this challenge ended up determining your competitive ceiling.
Professional athletes stand out not just through physical capabilities but through mental fortitude. The strategies we discussed—from pre-performance routines to visualization techniques—are powerful tools that work against performance anxiety when competition pressure rises. These methods work because they target both physiological responses and psychological patterns that fuel anxiety.
Note that perfect performances don't exist, even at elite levels. Athletes who accept this truth develop greater psychological flexibility and perform well despite discomfort. Their success comes from trusting their training, staying present during critical moments, and building identities beyond sports.
Peak performance requires dedicated mental training with physical preparation. Athletes spend countless hours perfecting technical skills but often neglect psychological conditioning. This imbalance creates weakness precisely when mental strength matters most—during high-pressure competitions.
The techniques we covered need repetition to become second nature. Start small by adding one or two strategies to your routine, then build your mental toolkit as confidence grows.
Sports anxiety shouldn't limit your athletic potential. These evidence-based approaches can help you turn anxiety into excitement, stay focused under pressure, and realize the full potential that fear and doubt once hidden. The gap between good and great often exists in the mind—you now have the blueprint to cross it.
References
[1] - https://share.upmc.com/2022/05/how-anxiety-affects-sports-performance/[2] - https://www.healthline.com/health/sports-performance-anxiety[3] - https://positivepsychology.com/performance-anxiety/[4] - https://appliedsportpsych.org/resources/resources-for-athletes/pain-tolerance-in-sport/[5] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10298221/[6] - https://www.drpaulmccarthy.com/post/understanding-shame-in-athletes-signs-causes-and-impact-on-performance[7] - https://positivepsychology.com/sports-psychology-techniques/[8] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10611030/[9] - https://www.elitembo.com/blog/freeing-the-mind-how-fear-of-judgment-sabotages-athletic-performance[10] - https://foxesclub.com/strategies-to-help-your-child-overcome-performance-anxiety-in-sports/[11] - https://www.peaksports.com/sports-psychology-blog/pregame-stress-and-anxiety-athletes-mental-roadblock-to-success/[12] - https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1750984X.2021.1944271[13] - https://www.athleticacademydynasty.com/post/manage-performance-anxiety-with-grounding-exercises[14] - https://positivecoach.org/resource-zone/breathing-exercises-for-athletes/[15] - https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24364682/[16] - https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2013/12/performance-anxiety[17] - https://www.peaksports.com/sports-psychology-blog/sports-visualization-athletes/[18] - https://www.drpaulmccarthy.com/post/how-visualization-techniques-can-elevate-athletic-performance-unleashing-the-power-of-the-mind-in-s[19] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7429435/[20] - https://www.drpaulmccarthy.com/post/how-professional-athletes-use-positive-self-talk-examples-to-win-big[21] - https://www.thedistancecollective.com/post/the-importance-of-focusing-on-process-over-outcome-in-sport[22] - https://www.olympics.com/athlete365/articles/performance/building-a-support-network[23] - https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21520704.2022.2164098[24] - https://sirc.ca/articles/optimal-performance-in-a-trusting-frame-of-mind/[25] - https://www.8020endurance.com/how-to-build-self-trust-as-an-athlete-and-why-its-important/[26] - https://www.drpaulmccarthy.com/post/how-to-stop-overthinking-in-sports-an-athlete-s-mental-preparation-guide[27] - https://completeperformancecoaching.com/2021/03/22/5-strategies-for-staying-in-the-present-moment/[28] - https://www.trainingpeaks.com/blog/mental-strategies-from-the-worlds-best-athletes/[29] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7739682/[30] - https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10413200.2025.2521267[31] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12476407/[32] - https://www.drpaulmccarthy.com/post/athletic-identity-research-new-evidence-challenges-traditional-development-models
